top of page
Search

Why Is It So Hard to Change Old Emotional Patterns?

Nov 11
6 min read

Close-up of a bearded man in teal glasses, lit by warm sunlight indoors, looking thoughtful beside a window and dark blinds.

You understand the problem. You know where it comes from. You may even know exactly what you need to do differently. So why does the same thing keep happening?

Perhaps you've spent years trying to understand why certain situations make you anxious, why you worry about what other people think, or why you react so strongly to things that don't seem to bother anyone else.

Sometimes these emotional patterns continue long after we understand where they came from

You've talked about it , you've thought about it, you have probably even read quite a lot about it. You might even be able to trace the difficulty back to something that happened years ago.

But, when you're faced with the same situation, there it is again.

The anxiety, the self-doubt, the overwhelming feeling that something isn't right.

It's frustrating, particularly when you know your reaction doesn't really fit what's happening now.

But understanding why you respond in a particular way isn't necessarily the same as changing that response.

And there's a reason for that.

Your Brain Doesn't Work on Logic Alone

We like to think that once we understand something, we should be able to do something about it.

If we know a situation isn't dangerous, surely we shouldn't feel afraid?

If we recognise that someone's opinion doesn't determine our worth, why should criticism still upset us?

So if we understand that a past experience is over, why should something happening today still trigger the same feelings?

The difficulty is that the brain doesn't rely entirely on conscious reasoning.

Much of what we do involves automatic processes shaped by previous experiences. Our brains are constantly making predictions, drawing on what we've learned to help us respond quickly to the world around us.

Sometimes those predictions are helpful, other times, they can produce a response that no longer fits the situation.

Imagine someone who was frequently criticised as a child.

They may have learned to become particularly alert to signs of disapproval. A change in someone's tone of voice, a particular facial expression or even a pause in conversation might have been enough to suggest that criticism was coming.

Years later, they may find themselves becoming anxious when their manager asks to speak to them. Consciously, they know there's no reason to assume anything is wrong, but the feeling appears anyway.T heir brain has recognised something that resembles an earlier experience and produced a familiar response.

The reaction can happen before they've had much opportunity to think about what is actually going on.

Knowing You're Safe and Feeling Safe Are Different Things

This distinction is particularly important when we're looking at anxiety, fear and emotional triggers.

  • You can know perfectly well that speaking in public isn't going to harm you and still feel your heart racing before a presentation.

  • You can recognise that a disagreement doesn't mean the end of a relationship and still feel an overwhelming need to put things right.

  • You can understand that making a mistake isn't a disaster and still become deeply uncomfortable at the possibility of getting something wrong.

In each case, what you consciously know and what you automatically feel are telling you different things, simply telling yourself not to worry may not be enough.That is because emotional learning doesn't necessarily change through reasoning alone. The brain may need new experiences or a different kind of therapeutic intervention to alter an established response.

When Self-Awareness Turns Into Overthinking

Self-awareness is valuable.

Being able to recognise our feelings, understand our behaviour and identify patterns can help us make better decisions. But there comes a point when thinking about a problem can become part of the problem itself.

  • Perhaps you replay conversations, wondering whether you said the wrong thing.

  • You analyse why you felt anxious in a particular situation.

  • You search for explanations for every uncomfortable feeling.

  • You might even find yourself questioning whether you've really dealt with something from your past.

The more you examine it, the more attention you give it.

And for some people, that can gradually develop into rumination, repeatedly going over the same concerns without reaching a useful conclusion. Instead of bringing relief, it can keep the worry active. There's an important difference between reflecting on something to learn from it and continually revisiting it in the hope that another explanation will finally make the feeling disappear.

Sometimes you don't need to understand the problem any better. You need the response to be different.

Why Emotional Patterns Keep Repeating

Think about someone who finds it difficult to say no.

They know they're allowed to have boundaries.

They understand that they can't please everyone.

They may have spent considerable time working on their confidence and self-esteem.

But when someone asks them to do something they don't want to do, they immediately agree. Only afterwards do they feel frustrated with themselves.

Why?

Perhaps they've learned to associate saying no with conflict, rejection or disappointing someone. Agreeing brings immediate relief from those uncomfortable possibilities, and that relief can reinforce the behaviour.

The next time someone asks for a favour, the same response appears.

It's not necessarily a deliberate decision. It may have become a familiar, automatic way of managing discomfort.

This is one reason people can continue repeating behaviours they genuinely want to change. It's also why telling someone to be more assertive, stop worrying or simply think more positively may achieve very little.

They often know all of that already.

Does That Mean Talking About a Problem Doesn't Help?

Not at all.

Talking about difficult experiences can be enormously valuable. For many people, being heard, making sense of what happened and understanding how their experiences have affected them are important parts of recovery.

There are also well-established psychological therapies that use discussion, reflection and structured exercises to help people make meaningful changes.

But people respond differently to different approaches.

Some find that understanding their experiences brings considerable relief.

Others gain insight but continue to experience the same automatic reactions.

This doesn't necessarily mean the therapy was unsuccessful or that the person hasn't worked hard enough.

It may mean that further work is needed, perhaps using a different approach.

And that distinction matters.

Because the goal isn't simply to understand why something happens. It's to help you respond differently when it happens again.

Working With the Automatic Response

In my practice, I often meet people who have already spent a great deal of time trying to understand their difficulties. They're not looking for someone to explain their behaviour to them. They want to stop experiencing the same anxiety, fear, avoidance or emotional reaction every time a familiar situation arises.

This is one reason I use BrainWorking Recursive Therapy (BWRT®) as part of my work. BWRT is a relatively brief, structured therapeutic approach designed to work with unwanted automatic responses.

Rather than focusing primarily on analysing the origins of a difficulty, it aims to help change the way a person responds to particular triggers.

It also doesn't require someone to repeatedly describe or relive painful experiences in detail.

For someone who understands their problem but continues to struggle with the same reaction, that can offer a different way of approaching the difficulty.

Depending on the person and the difficulty, that might involve working with learned emotional responses, changing patterns of avoidance, developing new ways of responding or building different experiences over time.

The aim is not to dismiss what you've learned about yourself.......It's to help you put that understanding to use.

You Don't Have to Spend Forever Working Out Why

Perhaps you know exactly why you worry about being judged.

Perhaps you've recognised that your perfectionism is connected to earlier experiences.

Maybe you understand why you avoid confrontation, struggle with confidence or become anxious in situations that other people seem to manage easily.

That understanding has value, but it doesn't have to be the end of the process.

You don't necessarily need another explanation, another book or another attempt to analyse every feeling, you may need to approach the difficulty differently. Because knowing where a response came from doesn't mean you have to continue living with it.

Understanding the past can help explain the present. But changing how you respond now is what can make the future different.

Ready for Something to Change?

If you've spent a long time trying to understand your anxiety, self-doubt or emotional reactions but still find yourself struggling with the same patterns, there may be another way forward.

I'm Lesley Allen, a psychotherapist, BWRT Level 3 practitioner and coach. I work with people who want to move beyond unwanted emotional responses rather than simply continue analysing them.

I offer sessions online and in Edinburgh.

Book a free 30-minute consultation to explore how we might work together.

 
 
 

Comments


Contact us

Lesley Allen is an experienced therapist, BWRT® practitioner and coach offering therapy and personal change work online and in Edinburgh.

 

Support is available for anxiety, trauma, PTSD, panic, confidence, stress, burnout, unwanted patterns and life transitions.

​

Sessions are tailored to you and may draw on BWRT®, psychotherapy, coaching, hypnotherapy, mindfulness and other evidence-informed approaches.

​

Online appointments are available across the UK and internationally, with in-person sessions available in Edinburgh.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • TikTok

Therapy & BWRT® | Coaching & Personal Change | About Lesley | Blog | Contact | Book a Free Consultation

bottom of page